Picture this: You're walking down a bustling street, stomach rumbling, trying to decide where to grab a bite for lunch. Amid the sea of options, your attention is drawn to a particular cafe.  What makes it stand out?  Why is there a line of people teeming out of the door and onto the pavement?  Intrigued, you wonder what's so special about this place that has people patiently waiting their turn, so you jump in line. Their food must be worth the wait!

A hoard of Google Reviews gives the impression of success and desire in the same way a queue of customers out the door does.

Welcome to the modern digital age, where information is readily accessible with just a click, and where the power of online reviews has transformed the way we measure a business's success and desirability.

In this blog post, we'll explore the dynamics of online reviews and how they can shape your business's image, both online and offline.

The connection between your online and offline reputation

Not too long ago, a business's reputation was shaped by three main elements:  word-of-mouth, print media, and personal experiences. 

Thanks to the introduction of the Google Business Profile (GBP) and Google Reviews in 2007, a whole new dynamic has emerged - where what you do in the "real world" is reflected back to others online.  

These days, word-of-mouth marketing is on steroids, 24/7.  Your online profile - your shopfront -  is now the first point of contact for potential customers.  With a swathe of positive reviews, you transition your offline customer experiences into online testimonials, attracting other like-minded customers in the marketplace.

Think about it.

Nowadays, you’ll catch people standing on the street, scrolling through online reviews and star ratings before they walk into a restaurant.  Maybe you're one of them?!  Sure, it looks nice from the outside, and they’ve seen some great-looking adverts for the restaurant in a local food magazine, but people are still inclined to check the online reviews before deciding to take a seat at the table.  

And at the same time, another shopper asks her friends and family for a trusted electrician to help renovate. The neighbour said they should use the local electrician they used for that light fitting last month, but when she Googled their phone number to book them in, she spotted they were rated 3.2 stars by 46 people. 

She notes never to trust the neighbour's recommendation again and calls the other Sparky rated 4.8 stars by 104 people on the Google Business Profile below instead. 

Keep reading to find out. 

Reviews are digital nuggets of social proof

Social proof is the psychological phenomenon where people rely on the actions and opinions of others to guide their own decisions.

Another name for it is the 'Herd Mentality'. Meaning the tendency for people's behaviour or beliefs to conform to those of the group. 

Online reviews serve as a form of social proof, showcasing real experiences from genuine customers. When potential clients see positive reviews about your business, it instils confidence and reduces uncertainty, leaving them more likely to follow the lead of the crowd. 

Whether it's a glowing testimonial about your exceptional plumbing skills or 230 people that rated your cozy bed and breakfast 5-stars, social proof works wonders for your reputation.

Reviews actively influence purchase decisions

Online reviews play a huge role in the modern consumer's decision-making process. Before trying out a new service or making a purchase, people often turn to online reviews to gauge the experiences of others.

Positive reviews can motivate a buyer, while negative reviews can raise red flags. Whether a customer is looking for the best plumber in town or researching the top-rated boutique hotel, online reviews heavily sway their choices.

Think of online reviews as compounding interest in your reputation bank.

Delivering excellent service + actively managing reviews = more Google reviews = more people visiting your Google Business page (GBP) = more customers + delivering excellent service = more Google reviews = more page visitors = more customers…

To infinity and beyond! 

Page one status:  The SEO benefits of Google Reviews

Being seen on the first page of search engine results can significantly impact your business's perceived success. And appearing on page one is a lot harder than you might think.  

Believe it or not, there are 6-pages of Google search results for 'Ohura NZ Electrician', and Ohura is one of New Zealand's smallest towns, so if there are 6-pages of competitors in this market, you can imagine how easy it is to get lost on page 3 in Auckland. 

Visibility is key, and online reviews contribute to your search engine optimization (SEO) efforts, making it more likely for your business to land on the coveted first page. As customers share their positive experiences and mention specific keywords in their reviews, search engines take notice, boosting your online visibility.

Reviews don't disappear

Online reviews don't fade into the background; they have a lasting impact. A review from 2018 will impact your online reputation just as much as a review from last week.

They shape potential clients' perceptions, influence purchasing decisions, and contribute to long-term brand image. 

Ignoring online reviews is no longer an option if you want to keep ahead of the competition. They're an integral part of your business's reputation, both online and offline, and require active management and engagement.

If you start proactively managing your reviews now, you could be flaunting your stellar online reputation in 6 month time. By getting ahead of the competition and growing your online review pool ASAP, you can set your business up for lasting reputational success in the digital space. 

See how betterbunch can help you get ahead of the competition. 

Damage caused by ignoring reviews

In today's digital landscape, where information spreads rapidly, disregarding online reviews can be a costly mistake. While it seems trivial, customers may perceive your silence as simply rude or even as an admission of guilt, damaging your reputation even further. 

Timely and thoughtful responses to reviews, both positive and negative, demonstrate your commitment to customer satisfaction and can help strengthen your online reputation.

Turning lemons into lemonade: Handling negative reviews strategically 

Negative reviews are an inevitable part of doing business. However, how you respond to them can make all the difference. Responding to negative reviews tactfully shows that you value customer input and are dedicated to improvement. Potential clients are more likely to trust a business that acknowledges it isn't perfect but actively seeks to learn, grow, and satisfy its customers.

A well-handled negative review can enhance your reputation as it allows you to showcase your commitment to providing top-notch service.

Fake reviews are damaging 

While the allure of a five-star rating may be tempting, resorting to fake or manipulated reviews can have severe repercussions. Trust and credibility are the foundation of a strong reputation, and if customers discover dishonesty or deception, your reputation can crumble. 

Authenticity is key, and genuine reviews, both positive and negative, contribute to a trustworthy online presence.

From ripples to waves: Impacts of a reputation crises

A single negative review can be manageable, but a series of negative reviews or a viral backlash can lead to a reputation crisis. These situations can spread like wildfire across social media and review platforms, tarnishing your brand's image.

Proactively managing your online reputation by growing your pool of positive reviews and quickly resolving problems is the best defence.

Tools for effective reputation management

As the significance of online reviews on your reputation continues to grow, businesses have embraced tools like betterbunch to efficiently manage and analyze their online reputation.

Platforms like this can help attract more reviews and offer insights into customer feedback trends, helping businesses make informed decisions and refine their services based on valuable insights. 

Adapting strategies for the digital age

In today's digitally-driven world, online reviews have become a necessity. Businesses must adapt their strategies to not only provide excellent service experiences but also to effectively manage their reputation online. 

Actively managing your online reviews is a vital part of fostering an impressive on and offline reputation.

You can have a fantastic storefront, an exceptional website or a professional marketing campaign, but if customers search for your contact details and find a weak star rating, your online reputation has failed you.

Key points  

  • Online reviews have a strong impact on a business's reputation
  • Reviews are a form of social proof that can be used to enhance your brand's credibility
  • Ignoring online reviews can lead to reputation damage; timely responses are crucial
  • Handling negative reviews professionally showcases your commitment to improvement
  • Online reviews heavily influence purchase decisions across industries
  • Appearing on the first page of Google Search results improves your perceived success. Positive reviews contribute to SEO and visibility, boosting your online ranking
  • Authenticity is paramount; fake reviews erode trust
  • Online reviews have a lasting impact on your business's reputation
  • Tools like betterbunch can help with effective reputation management
  • Maintaining a positive reputation requires adapting your strategies for the digital age.


In today's landscape, online reviews are more than just feedback; they reflect your business's identity. By understanding their influence and actively managing your online reputation, you can shape a positive image that resonates with customers, regardless of your industry, size or budget. 

how to write a standout business description
How to write a standout business description
how to optimise your google business profile with high quality photography
How to optimise your Google Business profile with high quality photography
google business profile q&a: sending the right signals to google and customers
Google Business Profile Q&A: Sending the right signals to Google and customers