Why local businesses must prioritise Google reviews

Google reviews, Facebook reviews, website testimonials, Yelp reviews... Yeah, it's pretty overwhelming! When you're busy, it can be tempting to put reviews in the too-hard basket, try to master all the sites and become the 'jack of all reviews, master of none', or turn your attention (and wallet) to a new marketing campaign instead.

But, the reality is that focusing on Google reviews is one the most important steps toward achieving local dominance in your industry.

When managed well, Google reviews have the power to build brand trust, influence consumer decisions and attract new business. If they're ignored, they can deter customers from your business, spoiling marketing campaigns, ruining customer perception and driving away business. on and driving away business.

But, hey, don't worry! We're not trying to scare you. Let's take a look at why Google reviews have fast become a key marketing pillar for local businesses, and highlight why attracting is more of a priority than ever before.

The tremendous reach of Google reviews

The first reason Google reviews should be a priority for local businesses is because they have such an enormous reach. Unlike reviews gathered on other platforms, Google reviews are displayed front and centre of some of our most commonly visited apps and websites, which is why they reign supreme. 

Here's why...

Google is the go-to search engine

With over 85% of market share, Google is undoubtedly the most popular search engine on the planet.

When a person needs a product or local services, Google is often their first place to look. With such widespread usage, potential customers will likely stumble across a business's Google review rating while researching their options.

A Google review rating sits directly below the business' name, turning it into a virtual storefront, and offering a glimpse into the experiences of previous customers.

Try it! Type 'local plumber near me' into Google and watch those stars stick out like a sore thumb.

Google Maps leverages your Google reviews

Google Maps is often forgotten by businesses when thinking about attracting local customers, but the truth is that it's one of the most popular ways to find a business.  Google reviews are seamlessly incorporated into these search results too. 

As a natural result of increased reviews, your reach further extends into this network as well. It's like having your reputation right on the map!

Google: the modern-day phone book

Remember the days of flipping through the Yellow Pages to find a business's contact details? If not, enjoy being young! After "the directory years" came the days of storing phone numbers in your cellphone contacts. In 2025, it's common to hear, "I'll just find their number on Google". That's because Google Business Profiles is the new phone book.

Your Google Business Profile is a digital business card—and it displays those sought-after customer reviews front and centre. 

Even after a customer decides to engage with your business, it's likely they'll still be greeted by your star rating when they search for your contact number or email on Google.

That star saying needs to do everything it can to help—not hinder—your chances of securing their business.

The mobile-friendly advantage

In a world where smartphones reign supreme, Google's platform shines. Its mobile-friendliness caters to the majority of users who rely on their phones for information. This accessibility has contributed immensely to the popularity of Google reviews.

Comprehensive information hub

If managed well, your Google Business Profile offers a treasure trove of information—address, phone number, website, photography, reviews, products and services, and even a Q&A section.

All these details in one place make it incredibly convenient for users to make informed decisions. Its "one-stop shop" approach is another reason Google manages over 85% of search engine traffic.

Google reviews: Dependable and reliable

The second reason Google reviews are so popular amongst consumers is because they are trustworthy and reliable when compared to other review platforms.

Here's how Google has positioned itself to be the source of truth for so many shoppers:

Google's brand is centred on trust and truthfulness

This one's simple. When it comes to online credibility, Google holds a position of authority.

Customers trust Google to supply relevant, data-rich information. The trust afforded to Google reviews by consumers is a natural extension of the brand's dependability in other areas like search result accuracy, data protection, and probably their stock price as well.

Google has zero tolerance for fake or spammy reviews

No one wants to be misled by fake or spammy reviews.

They're a common problem for businesses and customers alike, and for this reason, Google has developed sophisticated algorithms to weed out fake reviews, ensuring that the reviews on display reflect the most recent, genuine customer experiences.

Google reviewers must have an account

Unlike platforms where reviews can be submitted anonymously (or spammed by bots), Google reviews require users to have a Google account. It's all about that trust/transparency factor.

It's easy to set one up, and it's important to note that it doesn't mean you need to have an @gmail.com email address. This verification simply adds a layer of authenticity to the reviews, making them more reliable and trusted by consumers.

Readers and reviewers are diverse

Google reviews are left by, and will be read by, a diverse pool of people, ranging from regulars to one-time supporters, young and old, social media fanatics to consummate professionals.

This diversity has two benefits; firstly, it provides a well-rounded view of your business's performance and perception and, secondly, it means that a larger potential customer base gets to read about your great reputation—great for awareness!

A drive for reviews on Facebook is great, but the comments will go unseen by customers who are not active on social media. Similarly, you could have 300 raving product reviews uploaded to your beautifully designed website, but that won't necessarily help the thousands of people searching Google for the best mechanic in their local area.

Google reviews help you capture the all-important "active intent" market segment in ways that other review sites simply don't.

Interaction with Google reviews

Google reviews enable businesses to respond to their reviewers on the platform.

This capability not only allows them to address any concerns; it also shows appreciation for positive feedback.

This two-way interaction enhances the credibility of Google reviews and enables businesses to leave context to a negative review, or brand personality to a positive one. 

Google: The one-stop shop for information 

Once again, Google's platform proves its worth by offering comprehensive business information in one place.

Customers can gather all the information they need to form an opinion about your business from one Google Search result or one Google Business Profile check. This helps solidify Google's role as a decision-making companion. 

So, take a moment to review your Google Business Profile. Aside from reviews, how does it look? With the vast majority of search taking place on Google, and well over half of that activity being for local businesses - how do you stack up?

Take a look at our blog on writing a standout business description, or why ensuring your business information is all up to date and accurate. It all adds up!

Key takeaways  

• Google reviews are a key pillar to success in today's digital landscape. 

• Google owns 85% market share of search results, which means your Google reviews are more likely to be seen than review efforts on any other platform.

• Google Maps is one of the world's leading maps systems, and it displays your Google results loud and proud too.

• It's becoming increasingly common for people to Google Search your business for your contact details. It’s important that the results encourage them to call you and don’t put a potential customer off.

• Smartphones reign supreme, and Google reviews are designed to be mobile-friendly.

• Google is a one-stop shop for someone looking to contact you or form an opinion on your business. It’s important your Google reviews help and don’t hinder your reputation.

• Google is trusted, so Google reviews are too.

• Google filters out fake reviews and requires reviewers to have a Google account to ensure authenticity.

• Reviewers and readers of Google reviews are diverse, so Google reviews are often well-rounded and help attract a wide audience. 

In summary 

Tackling the overload of reviews from various platforms like Google, Facebook, and Yelp can be overwhelming. 

For local businesses, Google reviews' should be made a priority to help secure their position as a trusted business choice. 

Keen to start getting more reviews, but don't know where to start? Download our free Google reviews guide and learn the 4 steps to exploding your reviews... the ethical way!